Best French Onion Soup We’ve Made

This is the most delicious homemade French onion soup we’ve ever made. It’s easy, too. Thanks to the perfect broth, caramelized onions, garlic-rubbed bread, and melted cheese, it’s pure comfort food.

French onion soup is easier than you might think to make at home. Trust me. All you need are a few tips and a surprisingly short list of ingredients.

If there’s one thing to take away from this onion soup recipe, it’s how we cook the onions. Stirring them often is the key. Watch our video to see how we do it, or see our photos below!

Key Ingredients

• Onions: Yellow onions are the best onions for French onion soup. We have made this soup with sweet onions and found it a little too sweet for our tastes. A combination of yellow onions and sweet onions would be interesting. Red onions are spicier than yellow onions and will change the color of your soup. White onions are more mild and sweet, making them a good alternative.
• Broth: You can use chicken broth or beef broth to make French onion soup. We’ve tried all combinations (including using half chicken and half beef broth) and have loved them all. Beef broth is a bit more savory, while chicken is lighter on its feet. Here’s our recipes for chicken broth and beef stock. If you use store-bought broth, we’ve found chicken broth is a bit more forgiving, while store-bought beef broth usually lacks flavor and tastes salty.
• Wine: For flavorful, classic French onion soup, use wine. We use dry white wine and sweet vermouth, an aromatic fortified wine. We highly recommend using both, although substitutions are provided below. Also, if you want to make French onion soup without wine, see the tips section in the recipe.
• Bread: I use toasted slices of French baguette rubbed with a bit of fresh garlic to make them extra delicious before adding them to my soup. It’s the best!
• Cheese: The best cheese for French onion soup is Gruyère. It melts beautifully and tastes earthy and nutty, which works nicely with the savory soup base. If you cannot find Gruyère, substitute it with parmesan cheese, Swiss cheese, fontina, or mozzarella.

How to Make French Onion Soup

To cook onions for French onion soup, you will need to slice a lot of them (by a lot, we need 6 to 7 medium onions for a soup that serves four). I do this by hand. I peel them, cut them in half, and thinly slice them into half moons. To speed this up, you can use the slicing disk of a food processor or mandoline slicer.

Now, you’ll cook the onions in butter (yum) with the lid ON for about 12 minutes. This step softens the onions and helps them to release some liquid.

Cook the onions uncovered over medium heat, stirring often, until they look golden and caramelized. This step takes me somewhere between 40 and 50 minutes. Do you see why we started with so many onions? They cook down a lot!

Focus on the onions, and you’re 99% there to some of the best French onion soup you’ve had. Now we have our onions, it’s time to add the rest of the ingredients. You will deglaze the pot with the wine, and then stir in the broth, fresh thyme, and some salt. You’ll let the soup steep like tea for a few minutes, and it’s ready.

How to Serve French Onion Soup

While our soup sits, we can toast bread slices and then rub them with fresh garlic. This trick came from Chef Richard, and I honestly don’t know if I could ever enjoy a bowl of French onion soup without garlic-rubbed bread again. It’s so good.

Before filling our soup bowls, briefly dunk the bread slices in the soup. Dunking the bread in the soup before adding it to your bowl allows the bread to absorb some of the soup, so that it doesn’t steal all the broth from your bowl when you eat it. So smart!

Finally, you’ll add the bread and soup to oven-safe bowls and top with cheese. Broil until bubbly, and you are ready to dig in!

And there you have it, the most delicious homemade French onion soup we’ve ever made. I genuinely hope that you try it! To make this a full meal, serve French onion soup with your favorite salad. We love this balsamic strawberry salad with lettuce and cucumber.

This easy French onion soup recipe is part of our chef series, where we share recipes from our friend and renowned chef, Richard Hattaway. He knocked this one out of the park!