The Best Juicy Burger

The secret to the best burger patty is to keep things simple! You don’t need any extra ingredients for the juiciest hamburger. Trust me! Of all the burger recipes we’ve tried, this is my favorite.

We love a good burger, so we spent a few days researching our favorite way to make the best hamburgers. We learned that simple is best when it comes to homemade burger patties. There’s no need for extra ingredients! For thinner, more caramelized and crispy burgers, see our homemade smash burgers!

I love these juicy burgers so much (especially with our homemade burger sauce). To use ground turkey, take a look at our juicy turkey burgers and if you’d like a vegetarian option, I love these veggie burgers!

Key Ingredients

It may sound crazy, but quality meat, salt, and pepper are all we add to our simple burger recipe.

• Ground beef: For the best, juiciest burgers, use meat with 15% to 20% fat. Any lower, and you’ll lose some flavor, and the burgers will be dry. I usually buy ground chuck, but a ground sirloin is a nice option, too.
• Salt and pepper: I season my burger patty like steak and sprinkle them on the outside. There’s no need to mix the salt and pepper into the meat.

If you’re not convinced, we’ve tried adding extras like olive oil, cream, mustard, and grated onion. While we liked some, none were as good as a seasoned burger patty cooked in butter.

Olive oil didn’t add much, and the texture went a little funny. Olive oil made the burgers grainy, while cream made the meat tender. We both really liked it, but not enough to buy a whole carton of cream for a tablespoon (that’s all you needed to add). And while we both love mustard and onion with burgers, we prefer them added to the cooked patties, not mixed into the meat.

How to Make the Best Burger

I form my ground beef into 1/3 pound patties. They’re big but not overwhelming. A kitchen scale can help divide the meat. I also add a little dimple to the middle of each burger patty, stopping it from puffing up and keeping things uniform.

I season my patties before cooking. The more you fuss with hamburger meat, the tougher it will become when cooked. That’s why I season my burger patties like I season steak. I generously sprinkle salt and pepper onto both sides.

My favorite way to cook burgers is in a cast iron skillet or flat-top grill. We heat the skillet over medium heat, add some butter, and cook the burgers on each side for 2 to 3 minutes (see below for my tips on telling when burgers are cooked).

If you want to grill your burgers, go for it. We’ve taken our cast iron skillet to the grill with us. I love the sear you get on the skillet compared to the grates. No matter how you cook it, allow the patties to rest for a few minutes. I loosely wrap them in foil.

How to Tell When a Burger is Done

You’re looking at somewhere between medium-well and well in the photo below. I cook my burger patties to medium. The best way to tell when a burger is done, is to use a meat thermometer. I’ve shared the temperature of burgers when they are rare, medium-rare, medium, medium-well, and well-done below.

• Rare: Red in the center, 120°F and below
• Medium-Rare: Very Pink in the center, 130°F
• Medium: Pink in the center, 140°F
• Medium-Well: Grayish Pink in the center, 150°F
• Well Done: Gray, No Pink in the center, 160°F and above

Note: The USDA recommends cooking ground beef until an internal thermometer reads 160°F. I still prefer medium, but I wanted to make sure that you know.

What to Serve with Burgers

Upgrade your homemade burgers with homemade condiments! Ditch the store-bought stuff, make your own mayonnaise, or try this easy homemade ketchup. Keep it classic with sliced tomato, iceberg lettuce, and sliced onions. I love cowboy candy (candied jalapeños) and pickled red onions on my burger (they’re super easy to make and add a lovely tangy crunch). For something rich and creamy, go for sliced avocado or a dollop of homemade guacamole.

For burger sides, you can’t go wrong with French fries with fry sauce or these homemade tater tots. My son also loves these easy sweet potato fries. If you’d prefer a classic salad, try our pasta salad, potato salad, or simple green salad with this balsamic dressing.